black & bleu ice cream

Blue cheese and black licorice might sound like an unusual combination but the flavors work surprisingly well together. The rich tangy blue cheese adds a savory contrast to the sweetness of the ice cream while a ribbon of Australian black licorice brings a deep, slightly herbal flavor. It’s creamy, sweet, salty, and a just a little funky. Definitely not your average scoop.

Let’s talk about blue cheese

Blue cheese gets its distinctive veins from Penicillium roqueforti, a mold related to the fungi used to produce penicillin. Cheesemakers pierce the cheese to introduce oxygen allowing the mold to grow and break down fats and proteins creating its sharp flavor, creamy texture, and distinctive aroma. One of the most famous varieties Roquefort is made from sheeps milk and aged in natural limestone caves in France where cool temperatures, humidity, and airflow create ideal ripening conditions. Other varieties like Gorgonzola, Stilton, and Danish Blue use different milks and aging methods producing their own distinct flavors.

Licorice was once used as medicine

Licorice root has been used in ancient Egyptian, Greek, and Chinese medicine for thousands of years particularly for coughs, digestive issues, and respiratory ailments. Its natural sweetness comes from glycyrrhizin which is a compound roughly 30-50 times sweeter than sugar. Consuming too much real licorice can lower potassium levels, raise blood pressure, and even cause dangerous heart rhythm problems. So something that was used as medicine for thousands of years can also send you to the hospital if you eat too much of it.

History of savory ice cream

Savory ice cream isn’t some modern culinary experiment. By the 18th century European cookbooks were already featuring Parmesan ice cream including recipes that combined grated cheese with cream and sugar. 19th century American cookbooks also included oyster ice cream though those were often closer to frozen savory creams than the sweet desserts we know today. Before ice cream became firmly associated with vanilla, chocolate, and other sweet flavors cooks were already experimenting with freezing ingredients we would normally serve at dinner. So blue cheese ice cream might sound questionable but we’ve been putting questionable things in ice cream for centuries.

The strange history of cheese

Cheese has a surprisingly strange history! Tyromancy was a form of divination where people interpreted the holes, patterns, and changes in cheese to predict the future. Some pungent cheeses contain isovaleric acid which is a compound found in sweaty feet, produced when bacteria break down amino acids during aging. In Sardinia there is even a traditional sheeps milk cheese called casu marzu where cheese fly larvae break down the fats and proteins turning the interior into an extremely soft, pungent paste. Between fortune telling, bacteria, and live maggots cheesemaking has always been a little more interesting than simply letting milk spoil.

Let’s talk about food pairing

Food pairing is a lot more complicated than simply matching ingredients that share similar flavor compounds. While certain aromas can complement each other, contrasting flavors are just as important. Salt can balance sweetness, acidity can cut through richness, and bitterness can keep desserts from tasting overly sweet. Texture, temperature, and even what we are accustomed to eating also influence whether a combination works. Blue cheese and black licorice might sound like an odd pairing but the salty, tangy richness of the cheese contrasts with the sweet, earthy, slightly bitter flavor of licorice. Sometimes ingredients work together precisely because they taste nothing alike.

How to make black & bleu ice cream?

In a saucepan over medium low heat, combine 4 cups whole milk, 2 cups cream, and 1 cup sugar. Heat until steaming and just below simmer, stirring frequently.

Add the egg yolks to a medium bowl. While whisking constantly, slowly drizzle in about 2 cups of the hot milk mixture to temper yolks. Gradually whisk the tempered yolk mixture back into the saucepan. Reduce the heat to low and cook for about 10 minutes (stirring constantly) or until the mixture slightly thickens and coats the back of a spoon.

Turn off the heat and whisk in the bleu cheese crumbles. Once mostly melted blend until smooth with an immersion blender. Transfer to a bowl to cool, then refrigerate for 4 hours.

Meanwhile start melting the black licorice. In a saucepan combine the chopped black licorice with 2 tbsp sugar and 2/3 cup water. Keep simmering over medium heat adding water as needed and stirring frequently. Once melted cool slightly and transfer into a piping bag.

Churn the ice cream base in an ice cream maker according to the manufacturers instructions until it reaches a soft serve consistency, about 35-45 minutes.

Add a layer of the ice cream to a freezer safe container. Squeeze a ribbon of the black licorice on top, then add another layer of ice cream and repeat. Once all the ice cream and black licorice have been added stir it with a butter knife to mix the ribbon in more.

Cover and freeze overnight.

Tips

  • Put the tub from your ice cream maker in a freezer a day or two before starting this recipe.

  • Make sure your container is freezer safe - not all types of glass are fit for freezer and may break.

  • When tempering the egg yolks pour the hot liquid in a small stream while constantly whisking to prevent them from scrambling. If poured too fast the yolks will end up chunky and scrambled instead of smooth.

  • Churning is an important step in ice cream making to incorporate air into the ice cream base during the freezing process for a smooth texture and to control the size of crystals, but over churning ice cream can cause emulsion breakdown (fat and water components to separating).

  • A milder, creamier blue cheese will give the ice cream a subtle tang while a stronger variety will create a more pronounced savory flavor. Use 6 oz for more balanced sweetness and 8 oz if you want blue cheese to be more dominant flavor.

  • An immersion blender helps create a smooth uniform base without noticeable cheese crumbles.

  • Don’t over mix the ribbon; a few passes with a butter knife are enough to distribute the licorice.

Recommended products to make this recipe

*This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase after clicking a link, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Next
Next

swordfish steak with mango salsa